Tuesday, April 19, 2016

Mohna Ansari ; Nepals first female Muslim lawyer



Mohna Ansari ; Nepals first female Muslim lawyer
April 19, 2016
In this man dominated world, it is difficult for women to achieve something big especially to those who live in a developing country like Nepal.
But advocate Mohna Ansari proved her mettle   and shown the world  that everything is possible with firm determination and hard work.
Mohna Ansari
Mohna Ansari
Apart from being only female Muslim attorney in Nepal she is also the member of Nepal Human Rights Commission,
“In our community women’s leadership is not easily accepted. Our religion mentions equality, equal opportunity for education and even having the choice of marriage. In practice, however, due to cultural reasons, women leaders are not accepted by the society. I faced lots of challenges while I was going to school, at times my family was even asked why they were sending me to school.” She said in an interview with International IDEA.
A carpenter’s daughter, she studied in a government school and dropped out after a year in college due to financial problem.  A scholarship enabled her to restart  education after a gap of three years and in 2003 Ansari passed out as law graduate from Mahendra Multiple College of Nepalgunj becoming the first Muslim female law graduate.
After doing graduation, Ansari went on to work for global NGO’s, from where she progressed to UNDP and then to National Women’s Commission. It was while working at NWC as commissioner that she got a call from the Prime Minister’s office to join NHRC.
Now Mohna Ansari works earnestly for the rights of the marginalized section of society. Nepal having undergone significant political upheaval in the last decades is fraught with many human rights issues. Madhesis are a historically under privileged class who having felt neglected by Nepal’s new constitution rose in protest in Tarai region in September 2015. Government used force to subdue their protest and close to fifty people ended up losing their lives.
When Ansari raised the issue of Madhesis publically and question the use of force by army against the protest of civilians   she landed in the eye of storm. Criticism and threats poured in from several quarters. In her own words “It is very difficult to operate”.
Her approach to the UN Human Rights Council in Geneva, with regard to use of force against Madhesi protesters has not gone too well with the government. However she has the support of social activists and human rights groups. Amnesty International, Human Rights Watch and International Commission of Jurists come out in her support.
Mohna has also raised issues relating to gender justice and women empowerment and supports 33% reservation for women in government jobs. “I raised a lot of issues, especially violence against women, and advocated for a gender bill to end discriminatory practices,” Ansari told while talking to  Al Jazeera
She got recognition of her work and was conferred upon Suprabal Jana Sewa Shree award and the Nava Devi Award, both in 2012.
On her twitter page she writes ‘My life has a meaning. My misfortune has become useful to the community


JNU scholar denied her degree due to Afzal Guru row
April 19, 2016
0
JNU Protest
By Muslim Mirror News,
New Delhi: Chintu Kumari,ex JNU students union General Secretary alleged that the varsity has refused to give her MPhil degree in connection with a controversial event on 9th February during which anti-national slogans were allegedly raised at JNU Campus.
She is pursuing PhD in Political Science. She was found “guilty” of violating disciplinary norms by the JNU probe panel investigating the event against the hanging of Parliament attack convict Afzal Guru.
University officials said that certain protocols are to be followed when any matter is being investigated but maintained that they need to check details of the particular case reported Times of India.
While Chintu Kumari was issued a show-cause notice following completion of the inquiry by the five-member high-level committee, she was not among the eight students who were debarred from academic activities pending an inquiry reported.
“Today I went to collect my MPhil marksheet and I was informed by the administration that my degree and mark-sheets have been blocked by the Chief Proctor’s Office in connection with the February 9 incident,” Chintu alleged.
“The biased probe panel has so far not substantiated its decision of taking action on the eight students of which I was not even a part. Such arbitrary decisions by the administration are putting the future of many students at stake,” she added.
The JNU row has evoked nationwide attention following the alleged antinational slogan raised during an event organised to protest the hanging of Afzal Guru.Following the event JNU president Kanhaiya Kumar had been arrested and later Umar Khalid and Anirban Bhattacharya too were arrested but later released on bail


Condition of Muslims in West Bengal – Appeasement or Exclusion?
April 19, 2016 in 
2
 “Muslims constitute a very large proportion of the poor. The fact that Muslims in West Bengal are disproportionately poorer and more deprived in terms of living conditions is an empirical recognition that gives this report an inescapable immediacy and practical urgency,” said Amartya Sen while releasing the report entitled “Living Reality of Muslims in West Bengal” (The Hindu, 2016). This Report takes a stock of the condition of Muslims in West Bengal. The state of West Bengal is significant since 27.01% of its population is Muslims. Sachar Committee Report portrayed a very disturbing picture of Muslims in India. The Sachar Committee Report put forth a compelling narrative on exclusion and discrimination of Muslims in different fields including livelihood and education. Over a decade has lapsed since Sachar Committee Report was released. It is imperative that data related to socio-economic and educational status of Muslims is updated statewise. The “Living Reality of Muslims in West Bengal” (LRMWB) Report on the conditions of Muslims in West Bengal attempts precisely this.
bengal muslims, indian muslim, poor muslim
(Photo credit: TCN)

Context of West Bengal:-Political account:
The state of West Bengal has a rich intellectual heritage with liberal ideas and inclusive vision of Tagore and other stalwarts. The baul- fakir tradition is very popular in Bengal and reflects very strongly in different aspects of Bengali culture like songs, paintings and dance. This inclusive framework of culture and ideas has been germane for flourishing of religious reforms and progressive liberal ethos. West Bengal was ruled for 34 odd years by CPI (M), a leftist party, theoretic presumption being that it is ideologically secular and sensitive to the marginalized. Yet the Sachar Committee Report painted a rather sordid picture of the Muslims in West Bengal wherein it stated that Muslims lived in abject poverty. The Sachar Committee Report suggested that only 16.8% of the Muslim population lived in urban areas in West Bengal against 28% of general population in 2001. The infant mortality rate of Muslims in West Bengal was reported to be at 52 against 50 of the Hindu community while infant mortality rate under 5 years of age reported for Muslims was 77 against 68 amongst Hindu community. The literacy rates amongst Muslims in the state was 57.5% while that prevalent amongst Hindus was 72.4%.
In 2011, Trinamool Congress won a landslide victory and came to power in West Bengal after defeating the incumbent CPI (M). The CPI (M) evoked disaffection of the people of West Bengal and especially the Muslims after the Nandigram incident which created insecurity about land and livelihood. One of the factors that made TMC’s electoral victory in 2011 for state Assembly possible was the support of the Muslim community in the state had shifted to the TMC. Though West Bengal never reported major riots during the Left rule, it didn’t imply that Muslims had equal opportunities or that the polity was secular. On the other hand, Mamta Banerjee has attended rallies of Jamiat- Ulema e Hind, wore Muslim hijab, offered namaz but this mere politics of tokenism hasn’t translated into includion of Muslims. This isn’t much different than the treatment of Muslims by the Left parties in West Bengal.
Three approaches have  defined the policy of Trinamool and CPI (M) towards Muslims, namely, containment of communal violence so that it doesn’t assume critical proportions in terms of number of casualties and loss in property, political opportunism and tokenism- wooing powerful Muslim religious leaders for electoral gains, and not working towards the equality and inclusion of Muslims.
The numbers can shed more light on the electoral politics and the stakes to be gained by wooing Muslim votes. In Assembly election 2011, Trinamool Congress won 184 out of 294 seats (38.9% votes), Congress won 42 seats (9.1% votes), CPM won 40 seats (30.8% votes) and BJP did not win any seats (4.1% votes). Similarly in 2014 general elections, Trinamool Congress won 34 seats of 42 seats (39.4% votes), Congress won four seats (9.6% votes), CPM won two seats (22.7% votes) and BJP won two seats (16.84% votes) (Ibnlive, 2016). An extensive study on the Muslims of India by late Prof. Iqbal Ansari, later taken forward in West Bengal by Sabir Ahamed of Pratichi Institute, shows that 46 Assembly constituencies of the State have a Muslim “concentration” of more than 50 per cent. The figure is 40-50 per cent in about 16 seats, and 30-40 per cent in 33 seats. The data underscores that in exactly one-third of the seats, Muslim vote is the key factor to win an election. Moreover, in another 50 seats, the concentration is 20-30 per cent. Overlooking such data was possibly one of the reasons for the defeat of the Left Front in 2011. (The Hindu, 2016). This explains the scramble for Muslim votes by political parties like in West Bengal.
The LRMWB Report is particularly insightful in the wake of increasing communalization in West Bengal. The essentialization of religious identity of Muslims and stereotyping is leading to demonization of Muslims even in West Bengal where they have a sizeable population. The recent incident in Kaliachak is a case in point. The middle class urban population popularly called theBhadralok (Majority of the Muslims in West Bengal reside in rural areas) in West Bengal shape the public discourse by controlling sources knowledge like media and education. The increasing presence of the Hindu nationalists in some pockets work to polarize the attitudes along communal lines.  The communalization, essentialization and demonization of Muslims help RSS strengthen its presence in W. Bengal.
The LRMWB Report in the above context is discerning. The report written by Association SNAP, Guidance Guild and Pratichi Institute, is based on primary survey covering 325 villages and 75 urban wards from a sample of 81 community development blocks and 30 municipal bodies. The main findings of the Report present an undeniable yet absorbing narrative on the situation of Muslims in West Bengal. What is perhaps useful is the construction of the Muslim community. It is not viewed as homogenous but the complexities are dealt with while studying the various aspects of the community. The Report doesn’t limit the construction of Muslim identity to religion but takes into consideration other factors like region, language, occupation, educational levels amongst others which are determine access to various public services. The Report goes on to dispel many myths that are encouraged by media particularly about Muslim women and how they fall prey to the “orthodoxy” of the community. While it may have some grain of truth, the Report presents an objective picture in regard to education, livelihood, health and other amenities and how they are accessed by the Muslims. The Report goes on to assert that the particular state along with its specific socio-economic features determines the accessibility of opportunities to any community and not the religious-cultural identity.
Problematizing Educational status of Muslims:
In regard to education, the Report points out to a dismal picture. However there is a silver lining to this in the form of girls’ literacy rates in the state. For instance the Muslim literacy rate is 69.5 percent as per the primary survey, 7 percent lower than the average literacy rate of West Bengal as per 2011 census. The 2011 census pitched the gender gap in literacy at 11.1 percent in West Bengal; however the primary survey showed the narrowing of this gap to 7.8 percent. Also, the 2011 census stated a difference of 2.2 percent between general and Muslim women but the primary survey found equal female literacy to general female literacy of 2011 census. This flies in the face of the social stereotyping that Muslim orthodoxy prevented girls education and underlines the grit and aspirations of Muslim girls. This is especially significant since majority of the Muslim population lives in rural areas in West Bengal. In terms of the rural-urban divide, the literacy rate of Muslims in urban areas is 75.4 percent while that in rural areas is 68.3 percent. The female literacy rate is better than male under the age of 17 since boys are forced to drop out of school to earn a livelihood. At the same time girls do domestic work which enables them to attend school. But this situation is reversed when gender roles force girls to start a family and boys are encouraged to opt for higher education in hope of better income.
Another stereotype that is demolished through this report is that Muslim parents prefer sending their children to Madrasas since they are anti modern and against secular education. The Sachar Committee Report had pointed out that less than 4 percent of Muslim children go to Madrasas. This is not surprising given that there are never adequate numbers of schools in areas inhabited by Muslims. This is reinforced by the report which states that the number of primary schools per ten thousand population increases in blocks with a decreasing proportion of Muslims to the whole population thereby highlighting a pattern of exclusion. Further district wise distribution points out that the districts with a significant share of Muslims in their population, such as Uttar Dinajpur (6.2), Murshidabad (7.2) and Malda (8.5) perform poorly in combine secondary and higher secondary school as against 10.6 combined schools per hundred thousand population in other districts. Overall the Report alludes to the increasing aspirations of the Muslim community to get educated which is hampered by lack of higher education institutes close to Muslim majority areas in the state.
Status of Livelihood of Muslims:
Work Participation Rate (WPR) for this study is defined as percentage of population belonging to the working age group of 15-65 years who are actually working. It is reported that the Muslim WPR is 45 percent. Only 8.9 percent of Muslim women were found to be working. Though the work participation rate varies widely across districts, districts like Malda (13) and Murshidabad (21.5), women are mostly engaged in bidi rolling and embroidery work. Among Muslims in rural West Bengal, about 47 percent of all who work, work as agricultural workers or daily workers in non-agriculture. Only 1.55 percent households earn income as school teachers and 1.54 percent is employed in regular public sector jobs.
Income levels of Muslims:
The starkest finding of the report is perhaps the insights it gives into the income of Muslims in West Bengal. The Report spells out the extent of poverty with the finding that about 80 percent of the Muslim households in rural West Bengal report an income of Rs. 5000 or less per month which is close to the cut off level of income for poverty line for a family of five. Further, 38.3 percent Muslim households in rural West Bengal earn Rs. 2,500 or less per month. More than three-fourths of the rural Muslim households possess no land. More than half of the poor Muslim households in rural West Bengal do not possess BPL cards or MGNREGA job cards. 23.8 percent of urban Muslim households earn Rs. 2,500 or less. This poor performance on the front of citizenship rights points to inadequacy of the State to make democracy meaningful for such a large population.
Amenities enjoyed by Muslims:
The amenities available such dwelling conditions also give a glimpse into the security enjoyed by a population. It’s rather disappointing to note that 59.1 percent houses of Muslims in West Bengal are built with low quality materials like straw, leaves, bamboo, plastic, polythene, soil and mud bricks. On the other hand, 47.8 percent of general households are made of such material. Alternatively, 47.9 percent of the general populace lives in homes made of concrete and baked bricks, whereas only 36.6 percent of the Muslim population can afford such homes. The Muslim community’s access to tap water is nearly 40 percent less than that of the overall population. The availability of drainage system in Muslim households is meager at one third of that enjoyed by the general population.
Access to healthcare:
Healthcare, one of essential indicator of human development, accessed by the Muslim community depicts a sorry picture. The state average of the number of hospitals per lakh population is 1.8. However in Muslim dominated regions like Uttar Dinajpur, Malda and South 24 Parganas, this number stands at 1.0, 1.4 and 1.3 respectively. Similarly, the infant mortality rate amongst the Muslim community is 23 percent higher than the infant mortality rate in the Hindu community. The data suggests that Muslims prefer institutional delivery where the hospital is within accessible distance. This poses a strong counter to the widely held belief that Muslims orthodoxy is averse to institutional delivery. A case in point is also Kerala. The Report has dedicated a separate chapter on gender which in details evaluates the condition of women under various parameters but which is not included here in greater depth due to constraint of space.
Conclusion:
The contribution of this Report is immense by bringing into limelight the objective truth about the Muslims backed by such forceful figures. This counter narrative about the desire of Muslims for better education, livelihood and health amongst other rights makes it morally and constitutionally obligatory on the State to take notice and enable the Muslims to come at par with others. This report coming before the state assembly elections, hopefully, will create awareness about how the ruling dispensation uses vulnerable communities as mere pawns and vote banks for political power without serious intention of working for their inclusion and equality. This attempt can be duplicated by civil society organizations in other states to update the data about Muslims. Such reports will help in filling in the gaps in the data regarding vulnerable communities warped in exclusion, adverse public perception and discrimination

Monday, December 31, 2012

Supreme Court continued its judicial activism


New Delhi: From ruling that sleep was a fundamental right to urging the government to phase out the Haj subsidy in 10 years, to nixing guidelines on media reporting, the Supreme Court continued its judicial activism during 2012.
highlights of the more important judgements:
January 20 - Quashes demand for Rs. 12.000 crore tax on Vodafone, saying:
"FDI flows towards locations with a strong governance infrastructure which includes enactment of laws and how well the legal system works. Certainty is integral to the rule of law. Certainty and stability form the basic foundation of any fiscal system. Tax policy certainty is crucial for taxpayers (including foreign investors) to make rational economic choices in the most efficient manner."
February 2 - Cancels 122 "arbitrary" 2G licences, saying: "We consider it imperative to observe that but for the vigilance of some enlightened citizens who held important constitutional and other positions and discharge their duties in larger public interest and non-governmental organisations who have been constantly fighting for clean governance and accountability of the constitutional institutions, unsuspecting citizens and the nation would never have known how scarce natural resource spared by the Army has been grabbed by those who enjoy money power and who have been able to manipulate the system."
February 10 - Nixes army chief's age plea, saying the date of birth of General V.K. Singh (since retired) would continue to be May 10, 1950, as stated in his service record and not reconciled to May 10, 1951, as mentioned in his matriculation certificate.
February 23 - Rules that "sleep is fundamental and basic requirement" in frowning on the post-midnight police action against yoga guru Baba Ramdev's followers at Ramlila grounds in June 2011. "An individual is entitled to sleep as comfortably and as freely as he breathes. Sleep is essential for a human being to maintain the delicate balance of health necessary for its very existence and survival. Sleep is, therefore, a fundamental and basic requirement without which the existence of life itself would be in peril. To disturb sleep, therefore, would amount to torture which is now accepted as a violation of human right. It would be similar to a third degree method which at times is sought to be justified as a necessary police action to extract the truth out of an accused involved in heinous and cold-blooded crimes. It is also a device adopted during warfare where prisoners of war and those involved in espionage are subjected to treatments depriving them of normal sleep."
March 27 - Laments that criminals are abusing court process, saying: "One thing is crystal clear that criminals do not hesitate in approaching courts even by abusing the process of the court and sometimes succeed also."
April 12 - Upholds 25 percent of seats for poor children in schools under the Right to Education Act, saying: "It is not in dispute that education is a recognized head of 'charity'. Therefore, if an educational institution goes beyond 'charity' into commercialization, it would not be entitled to protection of Article 19(1)(g)."
May 8 - Asks the government to progressively eliminate Haj subsidy in 10 years, saying: "We have no doubt that a very large majority of Muslims applying to the Haj Committee for going to Haj would not be aware of the economics of their pilgrimage and if all the facts are made known a good many of the pilgrims would not be very comfortable in the knowledge that their Haj is funded to a substantial extent by the government."
August 29 - Upholds the death penalty for Ajmal Amir Kasab, the lone Pakistani gunman arrested during the Nov 26-29, 2008, Mumbai terror attack that claimed 166 lives, saying: "It is true that he is not educated but he is a very good and quick learner, has a tough mind and strong determination. He is also quite clever and shrewd. Unfortunately, he is wholly remorseless and any feeling of pity is unknown to him." (Kasab was hanged Nov 21 in Pune's Yerawada Jail.)
August 31 - Asks Sahara to return Rs.17,400 crore to investors, saying Sahara India Real Estate Corporation Ltd. (SIRECL) and the Sahara Housing Investment Corporation Ltd. (SHICL)
"would refund the amounts collected through RHPs dated 13.3.2008 and 16.10.2009 along with interest @ 15% per annum to SEBI from the date of receipt of the subscription amount till the date of repayment.
September 11 - Nixes guidelines on media reporting, saying: "No guidelines can be framed across the board to regulate media reporting of sub-judice matters...Finding an acceptable constitutional balance between a free press and administration of justice is a difficult task in every legal system."
September 27 - Holds that auction is not the only method to disperse natural resources. The ruling came while answering a presidential reference seeking its opinion on whether auction was the only method of allocating scarce natural resources as held by the court in its February 2 verdict cancelling 122 2G licences.

2013 will be challenging, uncertain for Indian IT industry


Hyderabad: The information technology industry in India has a challenging and an uncertain year ahead, feel the business leaders in the sector in this technology hub.
However, they believe the IT companies could use this uncertain period as an opportunity to make investments to increase their competitiveness.
"Such periods of uncertainly in the past have provided a great platform for organisations to refine strategy and execute initiates that increase competitive advantage and accelerate growth," said B.V.R. Mohan Reddy, chairman and managing director, Infotech Enterprises Ltd, a global technology solutions provider.
As a sector emblematic of globalisation and international trade, the Indian IT industry will also see a slowdown in growth, he noted.
The Indian IT industry's estimated export growth will be approximately 11 percent, down from 16 percent a year ago.
Mohan Reddy believes that the IT companies will look at expanding the delivery capability beyond India to leverage the global expertise, invest in creation of intellectual property and continue to improve the talent pool in the country.
Suman Reddy, vice-president and managing director, Pegasystems Worldwide India Pvt. Ltd, is of the opinion that the recovery of the global economy will have a positive impact on the IT sector globally as well as in India.
"Moreover, the Indian IT industry is witnessing a growth in niche sectors such as healthcare and insurance. With the healthcare reforms by the US to bring a new dimension to the Indian IT industry, we expect to see a lot more innovation and growth in the coming year," he said.
He wants the government to create tax reforms to encourage start-ups and smaller companies and to focus on public-private partnership.
With severe electricity shortage impacting the sector in Andhra Pradesh, Suman Reddy underlined the need for steps to improve the situation and also for widening the roads at key junctions in Hyderabad and for easier government interfaces.
According to the IT and ITeS (information technology-enabled services) Industry Association of Andhra Pradesh, the sector in Andhra Pradesh achieved a turnover of Rs.53,246 crore in 2012, crossing the Rs.50,000-crore mark for the first time.
Andhra Pradesh is the fourth-largest IT exporter in the country, accounting for 12 percent of India's total IT exports.
Ramesh Loganathan, vice-president, Progress Software India, hoped that during 2013 the industry would continue to improve its efficiencies and move up the value chain.
"Initiatives triggered by the start of recession in 2009 are now continuing to be relevant with pricing pressures and reducing cost arbitrage with wage increases and reduced growth.
"The modest 11 percent growth projected by NASSCOM notwithstanding, the efforts to improve profitability and to increase high value services and IP creation are actively underway, especially in Hyderabad," he said.
Pointing out that while Hyderabad is way better than other cities like Bangalore, with a better planned growth and good core infrastructure, he called for improving the public transport.
V. Laxmikanth, managing director, Broadridge Financial Solutions India Pvt. Ltd, believes that India's growth story is here to stay. "From the IT industry perspective, I see that it can be a great leveler and transform lives. The key is to make growth inclusive," he said.
He said while the "raw" talent base is good in India, the challenge is that the education system and social framework do not encourage independent thinking and creativity.

Tipu Sultan’s world’s first missile rocket gets due recognition


Bangluru: Tipu Sultan’s warfare technology achievements are finally getting recognition. A visiting delegation of Defense Research and Development Organization (DRDO), under its chief controller on Friday has decided to convert the ruins of Srirangapatna Fort of Tipu Sultan into a Missile museum, from where world’s first iron-cased rocket missile was fired.
Tipu Sultan, the king of Mysore, is also referred as father of modern missile technology when he first used the 2 k.m. missiles against the British troops in the Third Anglo-Mysore war at the end of 18th century.



Tipu's rockets.
But today Srirangapatna Fort of Tipu Sultan, a historic monument is lying in ruins with some walls getting collapsed with illegal encroachments all around.This has also shocked the visiting delegation of DRDO scientists.
Amazingly neither Karnataka state archeology department nor Archeological Survey of India has took the responsibility of conservation of the historic fort with has an international significance.
DRDO Chief Controller (R&D), Dr. W. Selvamurthy, who led the delegation was saddened on the appalling condition of the historic fort and the world’s first rocket court. Speaking to the press after his visit Dr. Selvamurthy expressed his disappointment, “Itis really sad and appalling and this matter is of a great concern. The place which gave birth to the basics of rocket technology cannot be treated this way. I am shocked to see that monument is completely clogged with encroachments on main entry and exit levels. A portion of the front wall is also lies collapsed with illegal constructions bonces on all sides of the court walls.”
Selvamurthy also assured that he will raise the matter to the highest level, “I will write to the state Chief Secretary, the Archaeological Survey of India and the state Department of Archaeology and Museums to restore and convert the monument into an archaeological center of great importance.”
Finally lifting the curtains from the plans of DRDO Mr.Selvamurthy said DRDO wants to use the fort to showcase the technological advancement of India which according to the DRDO scientisteven in 18th century was most advanced then rest of the world.
DRDO proposes to convert crumbling Srirangapatna fort and rocket court into a Missile museum to make it a tourist spot and to showcase India's technological advancements in Defense field.
Selvamurthy said the museum could comprise of “life-size prototype of BrahMos, wide range of missiles India developed like Prithvi, Agni and all ballistic missiles, besides having an original piece of Tipu's rocket at the proposed archeological rocket center.”

Movement against rape should be taken to its logical conclusion: Kaneez Fatima

Movement against rape should be taken to its logical conclusion: Kaneez Fatima

t
Hyderabad: The brutal gang rape of 23 year old Delhi medical student has shaken the conscience of the nation. Fighting bravely for past 15 days the victim ‘Amanat’ succumbed to her injuries and died in a hospital in Singapore after waking up the sleeping nation.
TCN spoke to Ms.Kaneez Fatima who is joint secretary at Civil Liberties Monitoring Committee. To know how she comprehends the incident and the events unfolded after it.
TCN: How do you perceive Delhi gang rape incident, and the nationwide protest which followed?
KF: It was a shameful incident and a crime in the most brutal form. But one should remember several incidents of this magnitude or even worse happens every day in India. Often carried out by Armed Forces of this nation in Kashmir in North Eastern states, and in the tribal belts with impunity under the protection of law. Many such incidents occur at higher percentage in rural India especially in villages, but often they don’t even get reported by the media or to the police.
This case acquired significance because it has occurred in the national capital. People should shrug off their double standards of protesting on rape cases. This case has generated a movement against the brutal crime of rape and should be taken to its logical conclusion.



Kaneez Fatima in her office. [TCN Photo]
TCN: What reason you see behind increase in the sexual crimes against women?
KF: There can’t be a single reason; it is difficult to generalize every rape case. After this incident a debate is taking place and people started commenting on different reasons like women dress code, as if women with traditional dresses aren’t getting raped. Rapes don’t occur because women are travelling at night, but it is expedited by the mentality of men.
Now this mentality and psychology of man regarding women just as an object of their lust is being created in their minds by emancipating social media. In movies women are depicted as “item girls”, and are presented as an object to satisfy the lust of a man. Even commercial advertisements to sell their brands portray women in vulgarity that hundreds of women are ready to fell for a guy, who is using products that is being advertised. Media should control its decency, and should play a positive role in changing the patriarch mentality of India.
TCN: What according to you can be done to control sexual violence against women?
KF: Protestors are echoing a demand of strict laws; some are chanting death penalty for the rapists. But people fail to understand that strict laws hardly control any crime. Strict laws cannot deter person who doesn’t have any regard or fear of law from committing a crime. First of all there have to be a total over haul in our judicial process, especially in regard to rape cases. So we can get some convictions, and so that rape victims don’t have to face the humiliation of the system.
There have to be process of reformation and awareness among the general public. Govt. on their side should take measures which ensure women are provided proper security and consciousness should be generated by the Govt. and the general public to counter the image of women generated by patriarch society as a product, item girl, or just a sexual object.